December 8, 2023
Breakdown of trust between Ministers ‘a threat to patient safety’ – David Cullinane TD

Sinn Féin spokesperson on Health David Cullinane TD has criticised the “blame-game bickering” between the Minister for Public Expenditure and the Minister for Health, saying that the mismanagement of the health service lies squarely with the whole Government.

The Waterford TD said that the breakdown of trust between the two Ministers, evident in documents published in the media, has resulted in a disastrous budget which presents a real threat to patient safety.

He added that Minister Donohoe has been responsible for public finances for six years yet seems to have a “dangerous lack of understanding” of the problems in the health service.  

Teachta Cullinane said:

“The decision to drastically underfund the health service this year was a whole of Government decision. The blame-game bickering between Ministers is a distraction from their collective responsibility.

“It only reaffirms the breakdown of trust between Government parties, which has presented a real and serious risk to patient safety.

“This Government has thrown in the towel on health and Ministers are now more focused on fighting among themselves, rather than delivering a health service that meets the needs of patients.

“The Government has rightly been criticised for its financial gimmickry by IFAC, and their nonsense approach makes a mockery of the Health Budget. The Government has not even funded the health service to stand still for this year or next year, and this will create serious challenges to meet patient needs in 2024 and into 2025.

“As a result, patients will suffer. They will continue to languish on trolleys and waiting lists. There is no new funding for the urgently needed 1,500 hospital beds, which ESRI researchers identified in an evidence-based report. Minister Donohoe knows this, yet he has chosen to ignore it.

“Minister Donohoe has been responsible for public finances for six years, yet it seems he has a dangerous lack of understanding of the challenges facing the health service.

“A decade of bad decisions under Fine Gael Public Expenditure Ministers has crippled hospital capacity and the HSE’s ability to manage its finances in a modern way. Minister Donnelly failed to stand up to that, and the Government has repeated those mistakes this year and returned to underfunding the health service.

“We all know that greater efficiencies are needed in the health service, and that far too much money is spent on outsourcing, agency staff, management consultants, and non-compliant procurement.

“Sinn Féin has called this out for years. Minister Donnelly has failed to clamp down on this. But deliberately underfunding the health service will do nothing to address that, and will only create risks for patients.” 

Follow us online

Latest Tweets

Every time we lose a family farm in Ireland, it pulls at the thread of our rural communities.

Sinn Féin strongly supports vibrant, family farm-based agriculture and will work tirelessly to protect our family farms in the EU. - @MacManusChris


Finance Minister @CArchibald_SF today brought a proposal to the Assembly to enable Ministers to award public sector workers a fair pay increase.

Irish Government must reject second term for Ursula von der Leyen - @mattcarthy

“Ursula von der Leyen provided political cover for the genocidal destruction that has unfolded in front of our eyes.”

This is a day of positive progress for the redevelopment of Casement Park as construction workers are on site.

Transforming Casement into a world-class stadium is a priority, and will create incredible opportunities to grow our economy, create jobs, and showcase everything that…

Load More